Effectiveness of ADR in Counter-Terrorism Cases as an Alternate Justice System
Abstract
International study and experience have shown that Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) is becoming a more prominent means of solving violent conflict, insurgencies, and disputes of a terrorist nature around the world. The conventional approach to counter-terrorism, based on military action, punitive action against the perpetrators and the use of coercive state power has been unsuccessful in bringing lasting peace to long-term conflicts. In this article, the author provides a critical evaluation of the effectiveness of alternative dispute resolution (ADR) processes in counter-terrorism situations, such as negotiation, mediation, reconciliation, restorative justice and transitional justice. It examines the theoretical underpinning of ADR in peace and conflict studies and assesses its implementation in the real-world context through case studies from around the globe such as Northern Ireland, Colombia, the United States–Iran conflict, and the Israel–Palestine peace process. The study suggests that although prosecution of terrorism is essential for serious forms of terrorism, relying solely on retributive justice often contributes to cycles of violence. An approach that focuses on ADR can help to prevent escalation of violence, promote political reintegration, help to de-radicalize, and help to tackle root causes of extremism. The article draws a conclusion that the form of integrating security enforcement with structured negotiation and restorative methods is more sustainable long-term solutions to the conflict over terrorism.
Keywords: Alternative Dispute Resolution; Counter-Terrorism; Peace Negotiations; Restorative Justice; Conflict Transformation; Transitional Justice; Mediation; Political Settlement; Criminal Accountability; Peacebuilding; Deradicalization; Pakistan.
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24115486
